| Manager of the Year Voting | ||||
| 1995 through the present,voting was on a 3-2-1 basis | ||||
| 2008 | ||||
| Chet Lutz,Rochester | 32 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola | 21 | |||
| George Tarantino,Sherwood | 17.5 | |||
| Tom Doran,San Diego | 6 | |||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford | 5 | |||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk | 2 | |||
| Mel Smith,Union Station | 0.5 | |||
| 2007 | ||||
| Harry Schiding,California | 26 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk | 17 | |||
| Tom Doran,San Diego | 17 | |||
| Carl Swift,Rocky Mountain | 14 | |||
| Dave Turner,Brooklyn | 6 | |||
| Jon Gerber,Philadelphia | 3 | |||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford | 1 | |||
| 2006 | ||||
| Carl Swift,Rocky Mountain | 21 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Steve Abrams,Philadelphia | 18.5 | |||
| Harry Schiding,California | 13 | |||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola | 12 | |||
| Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle | 12 | |||
| Tom Doran,San Diego | 7.5 | |||
| 2005 | ||||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford | 24 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Harry Schiding,California | 23 | |||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola | 13 | |||
| George Tarantino,Sherwood | 11 | |||
| Chet Lutz,Rochester | 6 | |||
| Bobby Fisher,Virginia | 4 | |||
| Dave Turner,Brooklyn | 3 | |||
| 2004 | ||||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas | 32 | Manager of the Year | ||
| John Franze,Cyrus Panzers | 21 | |||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 19 | |||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes | 6 | |||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes | 5 | |||
| George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine | 5 | |||
| Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers | 2 | |||
| 2003 | ||||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes | 34 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 25.5 | |||
| Harry Schiding, California Goldrushers | 11.5 | |||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas | 10 | |||
| Dave Turner,Marakesh Xpress | 3 | |||
| John Walton,Virginia Rebels | 2 | |||
| Eddie Kachnoskie,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 2 | |||
| Jonny Gerber,Miami Menace | 1 | |||
| Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 1 | |||
| 2002 | ||||
| George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine | 36 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 21 | |||
| George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress | 8 | |||
| Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 8 | |||
| Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers | 7 | |||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas | 6 | |||
| Dave Turner,Virginia Rebels | 3 | |||
| Jonny Gerber,Oyster Point Oysters | 1 | |||
| 2001 | ||||
| Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers | 23 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 22 | |||
| John Walton,Virginia Rebels | 12.5 | |||
| Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 10.5 | |||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes | 7 | |||
| Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas | 5 | |||
| Eddie Kachnoskie,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 4 | |||
| 2000 | ||||
| Steve Graybill,Oyster Point Oysters | 24 | Co-Manager of the Year | ||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 24 | Co-Manager of the Year | ||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes | 12 | |||
| John Franze,Cyrus Panzers | 10 | |||
| Carl Swift,Rocky Mountain Xtreme3 | 3 | |||
| Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers | 2 | |||
| Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts | 2 | |||
| Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 1 | |||
| One Abstention | ||||
| 1999 | ||||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes | 25 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 16 | |||
| John Franze,Cyrus Panzers | 14 | |||
| Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars | 10 | |||
| John Walton,Virginia Rebels | 7 | |||
| Carl Swift,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 6 | |||
| One Abstention | ||||
| 1998 | ||||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 21 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts | 15 | |||
| Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes | 13 | |||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 9 | |||
| Harry Schiding,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 8 | |||
| One Abstention | ||||
| 1997 | ||||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 25 | Manager of the Year | ||
| John Franze,Cyrus Panzers | 21 | |||
| Harry Schiding,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 9 | |||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 6 | |||
| Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars | 4 | |||
| Steve Graybill,Oyster Point Oysters | 4 | |||
| John Walton,Virginia Rebels | 3 | |||
| 1996 | ||||
| Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 31 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 19 | |||
| Harry Schiding,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 10 | |||
| Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars | 8 | |||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 3 | |||
| George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress | 1 | |||
| 1995 | ||||
| George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress | 21 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 20 | |||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes | 14 | |||
| John Franze,Cyrus Panzers | 11 | |||
| John Valori,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 5 | |||
| Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's | 1 | |||
| 1994 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes | 5 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Ted Knorr,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 4 | |||
| Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers | 2 | |||
| George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress | 1 | |||
| 1993 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 7 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Dave Buller,Dallas Texans | 2 | |||
| George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress | 2 | |||
| Billy Groff,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 1 | |||
| 1992 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Dave Buller,Dallas Texans | 4 | Manager of the Year | ||
| George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress | 3 | |||
| Steve Graybill,Rochester Rockers | 3 | |||
| Billy Groff,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 2 | |||
| 1991 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars | 5 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Ted Knorr,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 4 | |||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 3 | |||
| 1990 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes | 7 | Manager of the Year | ||
| John Walton,Virginia Rebels | 3 | |||
| Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 2 | |||
| 1989 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Ted Knorr,Pittsburgh Crawfords | 6.5 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars | 2.5 | |||
| Mel Smith Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics | 2 | |||
| John Walton,Virginia Rebels | 1 | |||
| 1988 (One Vote per Team) | ||||
| Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts | 8 | Manager of the Year | ||
| Dave Buller,Dallas Texans | 3 | |||
| One Abstention | ||||
| There was no Manager of the Year Award prior to 1988 | ||||