Manager of the Year Voting    
1995 through the present,voting was on a 3-2-1 basis    
     
2021       MOY
Billy Bell,Las Vegas 36 Manager of the Year Bill Groff 5
George Tarantino,Sherwood 17   Mel Smith 4
George Zangari,Billings 16.5   Phil Zangari 4
John Heiselman,Cleveland 8   George Tarantino 3
Sam Schall,Rochester 2.5   Carl Swift 2
Carl Swift,Amsterdam 2   Chet Lutz 2
Phil Zangari,Hartford 1   Harry Schiding 2
Niles Lane,Queen City 1   Billy Bell 2
Totals 84   Sam Schall 1
      John Walton 1
2020     Scott Fisher 1
Billy Groff,Norfolk 32 Manager of the Year Steve Graybill 1
Sam Schall,Rochester 21   Tom Doran 1
George Tarantino,Sherwood 11   George Zangari 1
Mel Smith, Union Station 8   Dave Buller 1
Dave Turner,Brooklyn 5   Ed Kachnoskie 1
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis 3.5   Ted Knorr 1
Steve Abrams,Philadelphia 2.5   Jeff Eichelman 1
Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle 1   Woody Kleinhaus 1
      Dave Turner 1
2019     Totals 36
George Tarantino,Sherwood 34 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 20  
Phil Zangari,Hartford 17  
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound 4  
Billy Bell,Las Vegas 4  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn 4  
Steve Abrams,Philadelphia 1  
     
2018    
Phil Zangari,Hartford 27 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 22.5  
Steve Abrams,Philadelphia 15.5  
Sam Schall,Rochester 12  
George Tarantino,Sherwood 1  
One Abstention    
     
2017    
Dave Turner,Brooklyn 31 Manager of the Year
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis 21  
Steve Abrams,Philadelphia 13  
George Zangari,Pensacola 11  
Billy Groff,Norfolk 4  
George Tarantino,Sherwood 3  
Billy Bell,Las Vegas 1  
     
2016    
Billy Bell,Las Vegas 28.5 Manager of the Year
Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle 23  
Mel Smith,Union Station 19  
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis 9  
George Tarantino,Sherwood 4.5  
     
2015    
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis 23 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 19  
Billy Bell,Las Vegas 17  
George Tarantino,Sherwood 14  
Carl Swift,Amsterdam 8  
Bill Groff,Norfolk 2  
Des Deeter,Maine 1  
     
2014    
Carl Swift,Amsterdam Bulldogs 24 Manager of the Year
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 21  
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis Sound 10  
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 8  
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 8  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn Metropolitans 7  
Sam Schall,Rochester Rockers 6  
     
2013    
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 20 Co-Manager of the Year
Sam Schall,Rochester Rockers 20 Co-Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 18  
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 12  
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis Sound 9  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn Metropolitans 3  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 2  
     
2012    
Mel Smith,Union Station Mystic Cowboys 28 Manager of the Year
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 25  
Bill Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 17  
Jon Gerber/Steve Abrams,Philadelphia Black Sox 12  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 1  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 1  
     
2011    
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 32 Manager of the Year
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis Sound 17  
Billy Bell,Las Vegas Crazy Horse 12  
Bill Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 10  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 7  
Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers 4  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 2  
     
2010    
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 31 Manager of the Year
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 28  
Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers 8  
Mel Smith,Union Station Mystic Cowboys 5  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn Metropolitans 3  
Ed Kachnoskie,Memphis Sound 3  
One Abstention    
     
2009    
John Walton,Virginia Rebels 24 Manager of the Year
Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers 22  
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 13  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn Metropolitans 13  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 5.5  
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 4.5  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 1  
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 1  
     
2008    
Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers 32 Manager of the Year
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 21  
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 17.5  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 6  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 5  
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 2  
Mel Smith,Union Station Mystic Cowboys 0.5  
     
2007    
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 26 Manager of the Year
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 17  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 17  
Carl Swift,Rocky Mountain Xtreme 14  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn Metropolitans 6  
Jon Gerber,Philadelphia Black Sox 3  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 1  
     
2006    
Carl Swift,Rocky Mountain Xtreme 21 Manager of the Year
Steve Abrams,Philadelphia Black Sox 18.5  
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 13  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 12  
Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts 12  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 7.5  
     
2005    
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 24 Manager of the Year
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 23  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 13  
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 11  
Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers 6  
Bobby Fisher,Virginia Rebels 4  
Dave Turner,Brooklyn Metropolitans 3  
     
2004    
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 32 Manager of the Year
John Franze,Cyrus Panzers 21  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 19  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 6  
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 5  
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 5  
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 2  
     
2003    
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 34 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 25.5  
Harry Schiding, California Goldrushers 11.5  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 10  
Dave Turner,Marakesh Xpress 3  
John Walton,Virginia Rebels 2  
Eddie Kachnoskie,Pittsburgh Crawfords 2  
Jonny Gerber,Miami Menace 1  
Chet Lutz,Rochester Rockers 1  
     
2002    
George Tarantino,Sherwood Forest Machine 36 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 21  
George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress 8  
Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers 8  
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 7  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 6  
Dave Turner,Virginia Rebels 3  
Jonny Gerber,Oyster Point Oysters 1  
     
2001    
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 23 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 22  
John Walton,Virginia Rebels 12.5  
Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers 10.5  
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 7  
Scott Fisher,Pensacola Piranhas 5  
Eddie Kachnoskie,Pittsburgh Crawfords 4  
     
2000    
Steve Graybill,Oyster Point Oysters 24 Co-Manager of the Year
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 24 Co-Manager of the Year
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 12  
John Franze,Cyrus Panzers 10  
Carl Swift,Rocky Mountain Xtreme3 3  
Harry Schiding,California Goldrushers 2  
Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts 2  
Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers 1  
One Abstention    
     
1999    
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 25 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 16  
John Franze,Cyrus Panzers 14  
Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars 10  
John Walton,Virginia Rebels 7  
Carl Swift,Pittsburgh Crawfords 6  
One Abstention    
     
1998    
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 21 Manager of the Year
Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts 15  
Billy Groff,Norfolk Neptunes 13  
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 9  
Harry Schiding,Pittsburgh Crawfords 8  
One Abstention    
     
1997    
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 25 Manager of the Year
John Franze,Cyrus Panzers 21  
Harry Schiding,Pittsburgh Crawfords 9  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 6  
Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars 4  
Steve Graybill,Oyster Point Oysters 4  
John Walton,Virginia Rebels 3  
     
1996    
Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers 31 Manager of the Year
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 19  
Harry Schiding,Pittsburgh Crawfords 10  
Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars 8  
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 3  
George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress 1  
     
1995    
George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress 21 Manager of the Year
Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers 20  
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 14  
John Franze,Cyrus Panzers 11  
John Valori,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 5  
Tom Doran,San Diego 76er's 1  
     
1994 (One Vote per Team)    
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 5 Manager of the Year
Ted Knorr,Pittsburgh Crawfords 4  
Chester Lutz,Rochester Rockers 2  
George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress 1  
     
1993 (One Vote per Team)    
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 7 Manager of the Year
Dave Buller,Dallas Texans 2  
George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress 2  
Billy Groff,Pittsburgh Crawfords 1  
     
1992 (One Vote per Team)    
Dave Buller,Dallas Texans 4 Manager of the Year
George Zangari,Marakesh Xpress 3  
Steve Graybill,Rochester Rockers 3  
Billy Groff,Pittsburgh Crawfords 2  
     
1991 (One Vote per Team)    
Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars 5 Manager of the Year
Ted Knorr,Pittsburgh Crawfords 4  
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 3  
     
1990 (One Vote per Team)    
Phil Zangari,Hartford Hurricanes 7 Manager of the Year
John Walton,Virginia Rebels  3  
Mel Smith,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 2  
     
1989 (One Vote per Team)    
Ted Knorr,Pittsburgh Crawfords 6.5 Manager of the Year
Jeff Eichelman,Ourinhous Quasars  2.5  
Mel Smith Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 2  
John Walton,Virginia Rebels 1  
     
1988 (One Vote per Team)    
Woody Kleinhaus,Seattle Scouts 8 Manager of the Year
Dave Buller,Dallas Texans 3  
One Abstention    
     
There was no Manager of the Year Award prior to 1988