Cy Young Award Voting
1995 through the present,voting was on a 3-2-1 basis
     
2023     Pitcher Cy's
Max Fried,Chicago 39 Cy Young Clayton Kershaw 3
Edwin Diaz,Amsterdam 12   Roger Clemens 3
Corbin Burnes,San Diego 10   Greg Maddux 3
Nestor Cortez,Jr.,Las Vegas 8   Darryl Kile 2
Shohei Ohtani,Amsterdam 8   Zack Greinke 2
Tyler Anderson,Rochester 3   Justin Verlander 1
Chris Bassitt,Rochester 3   Jon Lester 1
Christian Javier,Philadelphia 1   Matt Cain 1
      Roy Halladay 1
2022     Ervin Santana 1
Max Scherzer,Las Vegas 38 Cy Young John Smoltz 1
Corbin Burnes,San Diego 16   Derek Lowe 1
Liam Hendriks,Las Vegas 10.5   Johan Santana 1
Kyle Hendricks,Sherwood Forest 7   Tim Hudson 1
Robbie Ray,Hartford 6   Randy Johnson 1
Brandon Woodruff,Las Vegas 3.5   Mike Mussina 1
Zach Wheeler,Amsterdam 2   Brad Radke 1
Dylan Cease,Queen City 1   Kevin Brown 1
      John Burkett 1
2021     Bob Tewksbury 1
Trevor Bauer,Amsterdam 39 Cy Young Bret Saberhagen 1
Shane Bieber,Memphis 15   Mark Gubicza 1
Keta Maeda,Las Vegas 14   Jimmy Key 1
Zach Davies,Billings 5   Stephen Strasburg 1
Brad Keller,Cleveland 3   Gerrit Cole 1
Zach Plesac,Amsterdam 3   Trevor Bauer 1
Raisel Iglesias,Philadelphia 2   Max Scherzer 1
Victor Gonzalez,Billings 2   Max  Fried 1
Dallas Keuchel,Billings 1   Total 36
     
2020    
Gerrit Cole,Rochester 35 Cy Young
Dakota Hudson,Union Station 17  
Mike Soroka,Memphis 9  
Liam Hendriks,Memphis 8  
Justin Verlander,Philadelphia 4  
Jacob de Grom,Memphis 4  
Jack Flaherty,Memphis 3  
Luis M.Castillo,Union Station 2  
Jose Berrios,Norfolk 1  
Chris Paddack,Cleveland 1  
     
2019    
Justin Verlander,Las Vegas 37 Cy Young
Chris Sale,Philadelphia 21  
Max Scherzer,San Diego 11  
Jacob de Grom,Memphis 8  
Jared Hughes,Billings 5  
Noah Syndergaard,Sherwood 1  
Kirby Yates,Las Vegas 1  
     
2018    
Stephen Strasburg,Rochester 25 Cy Young
Max Scherzer,San Diego 23  
Adam Warren,San Diego 9.5  
Corey Kluber,Las Vegas 8  
Zack Greinke,Rochester 6.5  
Alex Wood,Philadelphia 3  
Clayton Kershaw,Billings 3  
One Abstention    
     
2017    
Clayton Kershaw,Pensacola 35 Cy Young
Noah Syndergaard,Sherwood 18  
Mark Melancon,Memphis 14  
Jon Lester,Las Vegas 13  
Julio Teheran,Memphis 3  
Andrew Miller,Philadelphia 1  
     
2016    
Zack Greinke,Amsterdam 24 Cy Young
Dallas Kuechel,Pensacola 22  
Max Scherzer,Amsterdam 18  
Clay Buchholtz,Las Vegas 6  
Gerrit Cole,Memphis 5  
Jacob de Grom,Memphis 2  
David Price,Amsterdam 2  
Matt Harvey,Memphis 1  
Clayton Kershaw,Pensacola 1  
Darren O'Day,Memphis 1  
Jason Hammel,Seattle 1  
John Lackey,Union Station 1  
     
2015    
Jon Lester,Las Vegas 37 Cy Young
Lance Lynn,Norfolk 21  
Corey Kluber,Las Vegas 9  
Darren O'Day,Memphis 6  
Johnny Cueto,Sherwood 5  
Doug Fister,Seattle 3  
Henderson Alvarez,Sherwood 1  
Jamie Shields,San Diego 1  
Zack Greinke,Amsterdam 1  
     
2014    
Clayton Kershaw,Pensacola 33 Cy Young
Yu Darvish,Rochester 16  
Matt Harvey,Memphis 16  
Greg Holland,Amsterdam 5  
Cole Hamels,San Diego 4  
Bartolo Colon,Pensacola 4  
Alex Cobb,Memphis 3  
Jose Fernandez,Brooklyn 1  
Jose Quintana,Sherwood 1  
Adam Wainwright,Norfolk 1  
     
2013    
Matt Cain,Norfolk 37 Cy Young
R.A.Dickey,Hartford 24  
Clayton Kershaw,Pensacola 12  
Kris Medlen,Hartford 6  
Jake McGee,Norfolk 2  
Aroldis Chapman,Brooklyn 1  
Justin Verlander,Norfolk 1  
Gio Gonzalez,Maine 1  
     
2012    
Clayton Kershaw,Pensacola 37 Cy Young
Justin Verlander,Norfolk 23  
Ian Kennedy,Philadelphia 12  
Sergio Romo,Norfolk 6  
Mark Buehrle,San Diego 3  
Ryan Vogelsong,Union Station 2  
Roy Halladay,Pensacola 1  
     
2011    
Roy Halladay,Las Vegas 37 Cy Young
Adam Wainwright,Norfolk 28  
Ubaldo Jimenez,Memphis 8  
David Price,Rochester 5  
Trevor Cahill,Memphis 3  
Joakim Soria,Memphis 2  
Shaun Marcum,Rochester 1  
     
2010    
Zack Greinke,Norfolk 32 Cy Young
Roy Halladay,Sherwood 22  
Adam Wainwright,Norfolk 8  
Mariano Rivera,California 7  
Tim Lincecum,Brooklyn 4  
Andrew Bailey,Norfolk 2  
Cliff Lee,Brooklyn 2  
Justin Verlander,Norfolk 1  
One Abstention    
     
2009    
Ervin Santana,Virginia 38 Cy Young
Roy Halladay,Sherwood 22  
Cliff Lee,Brooklyn 9  
Mariano Rivera,California 7  
Daisuke Matzusaka,Memphis 6  
C.C.Sabathia,California 1  
Jaime Shields,San Diego 1  
     
2008    
John Smoltz,Hartford 38 Cy Young
Jake Peavy,Rochester 20  
Brad Penny,Philadelphia 13  
Tim Hudson,Sherwood 6  
Bobby Jenks,Memphis 5  
C.C.Sabathia,California 1  
Chad Billingsley,Pensacola 1  
     
2007    
Derek Lowe,California 29 Cy Young
Roy Oswalt,Brooklyn 17  
Akinori Otsuka,San Diego 9  
Johan Santana,Hartford 8  
Brandon Webb,Virginia 8  
Tom Glavine,Hartford 7  
Nate Robertson,Seattle 3  
Chris Young,California 3  
     
2006    
Roger Clemens,Pensacola 33 Cy Young
Chris Carpenter,Seattle 25.5  
Dontrelle Willis,Brooklyn 18  
Mariano Rivera,California 3  
Joe Blanton,Rochester 2.5  
Pedro Martinez,Rocky Mountain 1  
Bret Myers,Philadelphia 1  
     
2005    
Johan Santana,Hartford 33.5 Cy Young
Randy Johnson,California 32.5  
Mariano Rivera,California 7  
Brad Radke,San Diego 6  
Roy Oswalt,Brooklyn 2  
Freddy Garcia,Hartford 2  
Curt Schilling,California 1  
     
2004    
Tim Hudson,California Goldrushers 31.5 Cy Young
Ray Halladay,Sherwood Forest  24  
Livan Hernandez,Norfolk Neptunes 18  
Hideo Nomo,Hartford Hurricanes 5.5  
Kevin Brown,Cyrus Panzers  3  
Brad Radke,San Diego 76er's 3  
Pedro Martinez,Pensacola Piranhas  2  
Mariano Rivera,California Goldrushers  2  
Barry Zito,California Goldrushers 1  
     
2003    
Randy Johnson,Rochester Rockers 35 Cy Young
Odalis Perez,San Diego 76er's 17  
Kevin Millwood,Rochester Rockers 10  
Barry Zito,California Goldrushers  9  
Mariano Rivera,California Goldrushers  6  
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords 6  
Jamie Moyer,Pensacola Piranhas  4  
Curt Schilling,Norfolk Neptunes  3  
     
2002    
Darryl Kile,Rochester Rockers 32 Cy Young
Mark Mulder,Marakesh Xpress 30  
Randy Johnson,Rochester Rockers 17.5  
Jamie Moyer,Pensacola Piranhas  6  
Matt Morris,Norfolk Neptunes  2  
Jeremy Fikac,San Diego 76er's 2  
Arthur Rhodes,Rocky Mountain Xtreme  0.5  
     
2001    
Mike Mussina,Pittsburgh Crawfords 25 Cy Young
Randy Johnson,Rochester Rockers 24  
Kevin Brown,Cyrus Panzers  15  
David Wells,Seattle Scouts  9  
Orlando Hernandez,California Goldrushers 4  
Kelly Wunsch,San Diego 76er's  2  
Billy Koch,Norfolk Neptunes 1.5  
Jim Mecir,Rochester Rockers  0.5  
One 2nd & 3rd Place Abstention    
     
2000    
Brad Radke,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 35 Cy Young
Pedro J.Martinez,Oyster Point Oysters 22  
Randy Johnson,Rochester Rockers  6  
Mariano Rivera,Oyster Point Oysters  6  
Kevin Brown,Cyrus Panzers 4  
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords  3  
Tim Hudson,California Goldrushers 2  
One Abstention    
     
1999    
Kevin Brown,Cyrus Panzers 28 Cy Young
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords  26  
Al Leiter,Marakesh Xpress  11  
Aaron Sele,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 4  
Curt Schilling,San Diego 76er's  4  
Jamie Moyer,Cyrus Panzers  2  
Rick Reed,Oyster Point Oysters  1  
Bartolo Colon,Norfolk Neptunes  1  
Jeff Shaw,San Diego 76er's  1  
One Abstention    
     
1998    
Darryl Kile,San Diego 76er's 25 Cy Young
Roger Clemens,Virginia Rebels  15  
Brad Radke,Pittsburgh Crawfords 15  
Jeff Shaw,San Diego 76er's 4  
Curt Schilling,San Diego 76er's 3  
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords  3  
Randy Johnson,Rochester Rockers  1  
One Abstention    
     
1997    
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords 20 Cy Young
Jamie Moyer,Cyrus Panzers  19  
John Smoltz,Hartford Hurricanes 17  
Mike Mussina,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics  4  
John Wetteland,Marakesh Xpress  4  
Bobby Jones,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics  4  
Roger Clemens,Virginia Rebels 3  
Kevin Brown,Cyrus Panzers 1  
     
1996    
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords 31 Cy Young
Hideo Nomo,Marakesh Xpress  14  
Shane Reynolds,Pittsburgh Crawfords  10  
Randy Johnson,Rochester Rockers  8  
Frank Castillo,San Diego 76er's 5  
Mike Henneman,Pittsburgh Crawfords  2  
Jim Abbott,Oyster Point Oysters  1  
Dave Veres,Marakesh Xpress  1  
     
1995    
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords 33 Cy Young
Jimmy Key,Cyrus Panthers  17  
Kenny Hill,Rochester Rockers  7  
Bret Saberhagen,Cyrus Panthers  6  
Hector Carrasco,San Diego 76er's  4  
Dennis Martinez,Pittsburgh Crawfords 3  
David Cone,Rochester Rockers  1  
Jeff Fassero,San Diego 76er's  1  
     
1994 (One Vote per Team)    
John Burkett,Rochester Rockers 9 Cy Young
Jose Rijo,Marakesh Xpress 1  
Greg Maddux,Pittsburgh Crawfords  1  
Kevin Appier,Hartford Hurricanes 1  
     
1993 (One Vote per Team)    
Bob Tewksbury,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 7 Cy Young
Mike Mussina,Marakesh Xpress  5  
     
1992 (One Vote per Team)    
Roger Clemens,Virginia Rebels 9.5 Cy Young
Greg Swindell,Pittsburgh Crawfords  1.5  
Dennis Martinez,Ourinhous Quasars  1  
     
1991 (One Vote per Team)    
Roger Clemens,Virginia Rebels 11 Cy Young
Doug Drabek,Pittsburgh Crawfords 1  
     
1990 (One Vote per Team)    
Brett Saberhagen,Unicorn Sound Magic Cosmics 10 Cy Young
Dave Stewart,Rochester Rockers 1  
Tom Henke,Virginia Rebels  1  
     
1989 (One Vote per Team)    
Mark Gubicza,Virginia Rebels 7 Cy Young
Danny Jackson,Pittsburgh Crawfords  3  
Don Robinson,Virginia Rebels  2  
     
1988 (One Vote per Team)    
Jimmy Key,San Diego 76er's 5 Cy Young
Frank Viola,Baltimore Unknowns  4  
Roger Clemens,Dallas Texans 3  
     
There was no Cy Young Award prior to 1988