| 2004 | Via | Round | Rocky Mountain Xtreme | |||||||
| P Esteban Loaiza | 1st | Carl Swift | ||||||||
| 1B Carlos Baerga | Hartford | 2nd | ||||||||
| C Gerald Laird | 3rd | |||||||||
| OF Luis Matos | Virginia | 3rd | ||||||||
| 1B Jeff Conine | 5th | |||||||||
| P Aquilino Lopez | 6th | |||||||||
| P Dan Miceli | 7th | |||||||||
| P Greg Miller (UC) | Virginia | 7th | ||||||||
| P Trevor Hoffman | 8th | |||||||||
| P Ron Mahay | 9th | |||||||||