| 2009 | Via | Round | Brooklyn Metropolitans | |||||||
| 3B Pedro Alvarez (UC) | Sherwood | 1st | Dave Turner | |||||||
| P Stephen Strasburg (UC) | Union Station | 2nd | ||||||||
| 3B Pablo Sandoval | 2nd | |||||||||
| SS Alcides Escobar | Sherwood | 2nd | ||||||||
| C Taylor Teagarden | 3rd | |||||||||
| OF Dexter Fowler | 4th | |||||||||
| C Jason Kendall | 5th | |||||||||
| Inf Aaron Miles | 6th | |||||||||
| 3B Andy LaRoche | 7th | |||||||||
| P Arthur Rhodes | 8th | |||||||||
| P Brandon League | 9th | |||||||||
| SS Lonnie Chisenhall (UC) | 10th | |||||||||
| OF Reed Johnson | 11th | |||||||||