| 2019 | Via | Round | Brooklyn Metropolitans | |||||||
| P Blake Treinen | Memphis | L-1st | Dave Turner | |||||||
| P Seth Lugo | 1st | |||||||||
| P Clay Buchholtz | Rochester | 1st | ||||||||
| 1B Luke Voit | 2nd | |||||||||
| 1B Ryan O'Hearn | 3rd | |||||||||
| 1B Steve Pearce | 6th | |||||||||
| SS Nick Ahmed | Philadelphia | 6th | ||||||||
| 1B Evan White (UC) | 8th | |||||||||
| C Reese McGuire | 9th | |||||||||