| 1991 | Via | Round | Hartford Hurricanes | |||
| 2B Tim Teufel | Virginia | 2nd | Phil Zangari | |||
| OF Alex Cole | Virginia | 3rd | ||||
| P Bob Tewksbury | 4th | |||||
| P Mark Eichhorn | 5th | |||||
| 2B Terry Shumpert | 6th | |||||
| C Joe Girardi | 7th | |||||
| P Jim Niedlinger | 8th | |||||
| P Curt Schilling | 9th | |||||
| 3B Jeff Bagwell (UC) | 10th | |||||
| P Rich Garces (UC) | 11th | |||||
| 1B Tim Costo (UC) | 12th | |||||