| 2004 | Via | Round | Sherwood Forest Machine | |||||||
| OF Larry Bigbie | Rocky Mt. | 4th | George Tarantino | |||||||
| P Dan Kolb | 4th | |||||||||
| P Josh Towers | 5th | |||||||||
| OF Jeff Davanon | 6th | |||||||||
| P Jeff Nelson | 9th | |||||||||
| P Kevin Gregg | 10th | |||||||||
| P Mark Guthrie | 11th | |||||||||
| P Jeff D'Amico | 12th | |||||||||
| SS Jason Bartlett (UC) | 13th | |||||||||
| P Lance Carter | 14th | Allowed an extra 14th round pick | ||||||||
| P Jason Marquis | 14th | to expedite the draft | ||||||||
| P Scott Schoeneweis | 15th | |||||||||