| 2006 | Via | Round | Sherwood Forest Machine | |||||
| P Jae Seo | California | 2nd | George Tarantino | |||||
| P Chris Spurling | California | 3rd | ||||||
| P Roberto Hernandez | Brooklyn | 5th | ||||||
| SS Neifi Perez | Brooklyn | 6th | ||||||
| P Scott Munter | 6th | |||||||
| C Russell Martin (UC) | Rochester | 6th | ||||||
| P Scott Schoeneweis | Brooklyn | 7th | ||||||
| OF Javier Herrera (UC) | 7th | |||||||