| 2008 | Via | Round | Sherwood Forest Machine | |||||
| 1B Carlos Pena | Pensacola | 1st-L | George Tarantino | |||||
| P Bobby Seay | Memphis | 2nd | ||||||
| OF Matt Diaz | 2nd | |||||||
| P Scott Downs | 3rd | |||||||
| P Manny DelCarmen | Rocky Mt. | 3rd | ||||||
| SS Mike Moustakas (UC) | Memphis | 4th | ||||||
| P Mike Timlin | 4th | |||||||
| P Vinnie Chulk | California | 4th | ||||||
| P Edinson Volquez | 6th | |||||||
| OF Willie Harris | 7th | |||||||
| P Lenny Dinardo | 8th | |||||||
| P Aaron Laffey | 9th | |||||||
| P Jeremy Affeldt | Brooklyn | 9th | ||||||
| P Jesse Litsch | Rochester | 10th | ||||||
| Inf Nick Punto | 10th | |||||||
| P Latroy Hawkins | Brooklyn | 10th | ||||||
| Inf Cesar Izturis | 12th | |||||||