| 2009 | Via | Round | Sherwood Forest Machine | |||||
| P Aquilino Lopez | California | 2nd | George Tarantino | |||||
| SS Timothy Beckham (UC) | Pensacola | 3rd | ||||||
| OF Brian Giles | Rocky Mt. | 5th | ||||||
| Uti Jerry Hairston,Jr. | Pensacola | 5th | ||||||
| P Joe Beimel | 6th | |||||||
| 3B Brett Wallace (UC) | Rocky Mt. | 7th | ||||||
| P Scott Lewis | Pensacola | 9th | ||||||
| P Sergio Romo | 9th | |||||||
| P Buddy Carlyle | Pensacola | 10th | ||||||
| C David Ross | 10th | |||||||
| Inf Jamey Carroll | 13th | |||||||