| 2016 | Via | Round | Sherwood Forest Machine | |||||
| SS Trevor Story (UC) | 3rd | George Tarantino | ||||||
| P Shawn Kelley | San Diego | 4th | ||||||
| P Tyler Duffey | 5th | |||||||
| P Charlie Furbush | San Diego | 6th | ||||||
| P Cesar Ramos | 6th | |||||||
| OF Ryan Raburn | 7th | |||||||
| P Tim Cooney | 8th | |||||||
| P Chris Young | 8th | |||||||
| P Addison Reed | 9th | |||||||
| P Miguel Socolovich | 10th | |||||||
| P Felipe Rivero | 11th | |||||||
| P Andrew Chafin | 12th | |||||||
| P Jhoulys Chacin | 13th | |||||||
| OF Justin Ruggiano | 14th | |||||||